CLOSE SEARCH
Disputes over commercial lease renewals arise when a tenant exercises statutory rights under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (LTA 1954) and the landlord opposes renewal. These disputes can be complex, costly, and high-stakes, requiring careful planning, robust evidence, and specialist legal advice.
For landlords, disputes typically involve defending claimed grounds for opposition; for tenants, the challenge is proving entitlement to a new lease. Understanding the statutory grounds, court approach, tenant breaches, waiver, evidence, procedure, and potential outcomes is essential.
A commercial tenant has the right to renew their lease if all of the following apply:
Business occupation - tenant occupies the premises for business purposes.
A genuine tenancy - must be a lease granting exclusive possession (not a licence).
Current occupation - tenant remains in occupation when renewal is sought.
Not contracted out - lease was not validly excluded (contracted out by agreement) from the Act.
No minimum term - any lease length can qualify, even short or periodic tenancies, unless for six months or less without renewal rights or continued occupation.
Lease still subsisting: The tenancy hasn’t been surrendered or terminated before renewal proceedings.
Courts carefully consider whether the tenant qualifies for statutory renewal under section 23 of the LTA 1954, has complied with lease obligations, and has served correct notices on time.
Landlords can oppose a renewal under section 30(1) of the LTA 1954, on the grounds of breaches such as that the premises are in disrepair, arrears of rent, or other breaches of covenant. Courts require breaches to be material and ongoing. Landlords must usually provide notice and an opportunity to remedy. Evidence such as arrears statements, surveyor reports, and correspondence is crucial. Successful proof may lead to refusal of renewal or renewal subject to conditions.
Other grounds, which may be hotly dipsuted include the Landlord claiming intention to redevelop or to occupy
Certain of the grounds, mainly related to the breach of lease grounds, are discretionary, meaning the court may grant a new lease even if the ground is made out. With the redevelop or occupy grounds, these are mandatory, where success prevents renewal unless compensation is paid.
The courts scrutinise documentary evidence, expert reports, and witness evidence to determine credibility and relevance. Courts are fact-sensitive and will not accept vague or speculative claims.
Waiver arises when a landlord implicitly or expressly gives up a right, for example by tolerating late rent or minor breaches. Landlords should act promptly and document enforcement, while tenants can rely on long-standing tolerance to strengthen their claim.
Landlords must act in good faith when specifying grounds for opposition. Opposing a lease renewal purely for tactical reasons or misrepresenting the basis of opposition can lead to compensation claims by the tenant.
Compensation may cover:
·Relocation costs
Increased rent at new premises
Professional fees for acquiring new premises
Other statutory entitlements
Courts may also award compensation where the landlord abandons misrepresented opposition after proceedings have begun.
Robust evidence is essential for both sides:
Landlords - business plans, planning permissions, board resolutions, and documented tenant breaches
Tenants - lease compliance records, payment history, and procedural errors
Experts - surveyors, valuers, and accountants can provide evidence on market rent, repairs, dilapidations, and redevelopment feasibility
Expert evidence is often critical but adds significantly to costs.
Grant of a new lease – usually similar to the existing lease, with possible adjustments to rent or obligations
Dismissal of tenant claim – if landlord proves valid statutory grounds
Conditional renewal – courts may impose conditions such as payment of arrears or compliance with covenants
Partial remedies – shorter term or adjusted terms if only some grounds are accepted
For advice on disputed commercial lease renewals, statutory rights, or court proceedings, please contact us. Our specialist property litigation team provides strategic guidance, representation, and practical solutions to protect your interests and achieve the best outcome.
Get in touch
If you would like to speak with a member of the team you can contact us on:
