CLOSE SEARCH
Executors are legally responsible for managing a deceased person’s estate, collecting assets, paying debts and taxes, and distributing inheritance according to the will. Executor negligence occurs when an executor fails to perform these duties with reasonable care and competence, leading to financial loss, delays, or unfair treatment of beneficiaries. This can include delays without good reason, mismanaging estate assets, failing to pay taxes or debts, ignoring the will’s instructions, or acting in their own interest.
Professional executors (like solicitors) are held to a higher standard than lay executors (family or friends), but all can be personally liable if negligent. This guide explains common forms of executor negligence, how negligence claims work under English law, the challenges in proving them, and what remedies are available to beneficiaries.
Executors can be either:
Lay Executors: Usually family members or friends appointed by the deceased. They are unpaid (except for expense reimbursement) and are judged on what a reasonable person in their position would do, given they may lack legal or financial expertise.
Professional Executors: Such as solicitors, accountants, or trust companies who administer estates for a fee. They are held to a higher standard, expected to perform to the level of a competent professional in their field.
This distinction matters in negligence claims. Professionals face stricter scrutiny for errors or omissions, while lay executors have some allowance for acting without expert knowledge, provided they act honestly and reasonably.
Executor negligence happens when an executor breaches their duty to administer the estate with due care and skill, causing financial loss or other harm to beneficiaries or the estate.
Unreasonable Delays - executors must act within a reasonable timeframe, but delays caused by estate complexity or legal hurdles may be justified. Negligence arises when delays are unexplained or avoidable.
Mismanagement of Assets - executors must protect estate assets and act prudently with investments or sales. As an example, not insuring a valuable property that is later damaged or selling estate assets below market value without proper consent.
Failure to Pay Debts or Taxes - timely payment of debts, inheritance tax, and other liabilities is essential. Delays can lead to penalties.
Ignoring or Misapplying the Will - executors must follow the will exactly. Distributing assets incorrectly or to unintended beneficiaries breaches their duty.
Conflict of Interest or Self-Dealing - executors must avoid benefiting personally from the estate unless authorised. for example, an executor is not allowed legally to sell estate property to themselves at a discount without agreement from other beneficiaries.
To prove negligence, a claimant (usually a beneficiary) must establish:
The executor owed a duty of care (which is automatic by virtue of their role),
There was a breach of that duty through unreasonable conduct or failure to act,
The breach caused a loss to the estate or beneficiary, and
The loss is measurable and provable (usually financial).
Not Every Mistake Is Negligence - executors are given leeway, especially lay executors acting in good faith. Complex estates often require time and careful steps, which can explain delays or errors.
Proving Breach and Loss - beneficiaries must show the executor acted unreasonably and that this caused an actual loss. A simple error or delay is not enough without showing it directly led to harm.
Causation - even if an executor breached their duty, it must be proven legally that this breach caused the specific financial loss or damage claimed. If the loss would have happened regardless, the claim may fail.
Time Limits - claims usually must be brought within six years of the negligent act.
Executor negligence claims are made against the individual executor(s) personally. If an executor breaches their duties, they can be held personally liable to compensate the estate or beneficiaries.
Where there are multiple executors appointed jointly, liability is typically joint and several. This means:
Each executor is responsible for the entire administration of the estate.
A claimant can pursue one or more executors for the full amount of any loss.
An executor who pays more than their fair share can seek contribution from co-executors who were not negligent.
Executors should therefore communicate and co-operate closely, as they share responsibility. Professional executors often have insurance to cover negligence claims, but lay executors generally do not.
If negligence is established, the court may order:
Financial compensation payable by the negligent executor personally, to restore the estate’s value,
Removal or replacement of the executor to protect the estate,
Court directions on how the estate should be administered moving forward.
Whether you are an executor trying to navigate your duties or a beneficiary concerned about possible executor negligence, we provide clear, practical advice to guide you through this often complex area of law.
For Executors
Understanding Your Duties - we help you grasp your legal responsibilities, whether you are a layperson or a professional executor, so you can carry out estate administration properly.
Avoiding Negligence - our advice can help you identify common pitfalls and how to avoid delays, mismanagement, or breaches of duty.
Addressing Concerns Early - if you recognise you are unable to handle the role effectively, due to complexity, time constraints, or lack of expertise, we can advise on early renunciation (stepping down before taking on the role) or applying for removal to prevent future problems.
Resolving Disputes - if disagreements arise with beneficiaries or co-executors, we guide you through dispute resolution or court processes if necessary.
For Beneficiaries
Assessing Executor Conduct - we assist you in identifying whether executor actions or delays may amount to negligence or breach of duty.
Protecting Your Interests - if you suspect mismanagement, we advise on the practical steps you can take, including requesting information, mediation, or raising concerns formally.
Bringing Claims - we support you in bringing claims against negligent executors for compensation or seeking their removal to protect the estate.
Alternative Solutions - sometimes early action to have an incompetent executor removed or replaced can save time, money, and stress. We help you understand your options and how to proceed.
No matter your position, early advice is key to preventing loss and resolving issues effectively. Contact us to discuss your situation confidentially and receive tailored guidance.
Get in touch
If you would like to speak with a member of the team you can contact us on:
Director of Dispute Resolution
Meta started her legal career working on insolvency disputes, advising insolvency practitioners, directors and debtors facing claims from liquidators or trustees. She gained valuable experience in managing trading businesses whilst working for one of t...
