CLOSE SEARCH
We acted for a residential accommodation operator which held a five-year lease, running from March 2022 to February 2027, of a 23-unit apartment building in West London, which it operated as short-stay serviced accommodation. The lease was supported by a guarantee from an overseas group company and a £70,000 rent deposit.
In 2024 the landlord forfeited the lease for rent arrears. We secured relief from forfeiture, reduced the sums claimed and restored the lease on payment of just over £174,000 in November 2024. Within weeks, however, arrears were again accruing, and in January 2025 the landlord served a statutory demand on the tenant company, opening the way to a winding-up petition.
A petition would have been far more damaging than the debt itself. Once presented and advertised, it would have put the client's bank accounts and trading at risk and exposed the guarantor and the wider group. Our strategy was to stop a petition being presented, keep control of the timetable and turn the landlord's insolvency threat into a negotiated exit.
The challenges to be addressed included:
1. A statutory demand for a lease debt, with only 21 days before the landlord could present a petition, from a landlord that had already shown it was prepared to enforce by forfeiting the lease and issuing possession proceedings.
2. Limited scope to dispute the core debt: the landlord described the arrears as well documented and a crystallised debt, so a straightforward challenge to the demand on the basis that the debt was disputed was not available.
3. The serious consequences of a petition for an operating business: advertisement, the likely freezing of bank accounts, disruption to trading and exposure for the guarantor and the wider group.
4. The landlord's opening position that any surrender had to be conditional on payment of all arrears and legal costs up to the date of surrender, while arrears of rent and insurance rent continued to accrue.
5. Delivering the exit quickly and securely, including vacant possession of 23 units, the landlord's pre-completion enquiries, an inspection and handover, and a tenant and guarantor based abroad.
1. Early engagement within the statutory period
We did not wait for the 21 days to run. Within a week of the statutory demand we sent a without prejudice settlement proposal to the landlord's solicitors. They asked for the deadline for acceptance to be extended to 7 February 2025 so that they could investigate the points raised, which kept the landlord engaged in negotiation rather than preparing a petition.
2. Using a cross-claim as leverage against the petition
The centrepiece of our strategy was a counterclaim for the landlord's failure to repair and maintain the retained parts of the building, which had left at least two flats uninhabitable. A creditor whose debt is met by a genuine and substantial cross-claim takes a real risk in presenting a winding-up petition, so raising the counterclaim meant that any petition was likely to be contested. The landlord did not accept the counterclaim, but it put its petition instructions on hold and agreed that a surrender was the only commercial way forward.
3. Securing an open undertaking before the deadline expired
Conscious that the 21-day period was about to expire, we asked for an undertaking that no petition would be presented without 10 days' notice and insisted that it be given on an open basis, even though negotiations were without prejudice. The landlord gave it on 10 February 2025, before the period ended. Because it was open, the client could rely on it in court: if talks broke down, it would have time to apply to restrain presentation of a petition. This removed the risk of a petition appearing without warning and kept negotiations alive when progress stalled later that month.
4. Moving the landlord from payment in full to a mutual walk-away
With the petition threat contained, we negotiated the terms of exit. We used the counterclaim, the value to the landlord of early vacant possession of a fully furnished, operational building and the landlord's interest in avoiding contested insolvency proceedings to move it away from its demand that all arrears and costs be paid first. The landlord's rent deposit and its dilapidations claim were traded against each other, so that the landlord kept the deposit and the furniture in return for waiving dilapidations.
5. Closing off the insolvency risk in the deed of surrender
We made sure the deed of surrender dealt with the statutory demand expressly. The landlord withdrew the statutory demand and undertook not to present a petition based on it, and waived all outstanding sums due under the lease or otherwise, including its legal costs. The tenant and guarantor waived their counterclaims and were released from the tenant covenants. We then managed completion, including replies to the landlord's enquiries on occupiers, TUPE and outgoings, and the inspection and handover of the building in April 2025.
No winding-up petition was ever presented or advertised. The client's bank accounts and trading were unaffected, the statutory demand was withdrawn with an undertaking not to petition on it, and the guarantor was fully released. A situation that began as a threatened compulsory liquidation of the tenant company ended without any insolvency process at all.
Commercially, the client left a lease with almost two years still to run, at a rent of about £437,000 a year, without paying the outstanding arrears or the landlord's legal costs, and with no exposure to dilapidations. Taken together with the earlier relief from forfeiture, our approach protected the client's business while it needed the building and secured a clean exit when it no longer did.
Get in touch
If you would like to speak with a member of the team you can contact us on: